Buffalo Trace Bourbon – A Legacy of American Whiskey Excellence

Introduction

When it comes to iconic American bourbon, few names carry as much weight as Buffalo Trace. With over 200 years of distilling tradition, Buffalo Trace is not only one of the oldest operating distilleries in the United States, but it’s also among the most awarded. Known for its rich heritage, masterful aging processes, and high-quality flavor profiles, Buffalo Trace is a must-know brand for bourbon lovers and collectors alike.

In this guide, we’ll explore the full story of Buffalo Trace—from its historical roots and distillation process to tasting notes, popular expressions, and why it holds such a revered spot in the world of whiskey.

The History of Buffalo Trace

Buffalo Trace Distillery, located in Frankfort, Kentucky, dates back to 1775, making it one of the oldest continuously operating distilleries in the U.S. Even during Prohibition, it remained operational for “medicinal purposes.” Over the years, it’s passed through multiple hands and names (like George T. Stagg Distillery) before being renamed Buffalo Trace in 1999 by the Sazerac Company.

Its location is historically significant—early American pioneers followed buffalo migration trails across the Kentucky River, hence the name Buffalo Trace. This connection to the American frontier adds a layer of cultural depth that resonates with bourbon purists and newcomers alike.

What Makes Buffalo Trace Bourbon Special?

✅ Award-Winning Reputation

Buffalo Trace has earned more than 500 industry awards, including prestigious medals from the San Francisco World Spirits Competition and Whisky Magazine. The flagship Buffalo Trace Bourbon offers remarkable quality for its price and is a regular favorite among both critics and casual drinkers.

✅ Traditional Craftsmanship

Buffalo Trace uses locally sourced grains, a sour mash fermentation process, and new charred oak barrels to create its signature bourbon. Aging takes place in temperature-controlled warehouses on the Frankfort property, with some barrels aging for over a decade.

✅ Iconic Mash Bills

The distillery produces multiple mash bills:

  • Mash Bill #1: Low-rye bourbon (used in Buffalo Trace, George T. Stagg, Eagle Rare)
  • Mash Bill #2: High-rye bourbon (used in Blanton’s, Elmer T. Lee)
  • Wheated Mash Bill: (used in Weller and Pappy Van Winkle)

Popular Buffalo Trace Expressions

  1. Buffalo Trace Bourbon (Flagship)
    • Aged ~8 years
    • Notes of caramel, vanilla, and spice
    • Perfect for sipping or mixing
  2. Eagle Rare 10-Year
    • A smoother, more refined profile with oak and dark fruit
  3. Blanton’s Single Barrel
    • First commercially available single-barrel bourbon
    • Rich, complex, and highly collectible
  4. Stagg Jr. / George T. Stagg
    • Barrel-proof, bold, and intense
    • Not for the faint of heart
  5. Weller Series
    • Wheated bourbons often compared to Pappy Van Winkle
    • Includes Weller Special Reserve, Antique 107, and Full Proof
  6. Pappy Van Winkle Family Reserve
    • Rare, highly sought-after, and extremely limited
    • Often sells for thousands on secondary markets

Tasting Notes: Buffalo Trace Bourbon

  • Appearance: Deep amber
  • Nose: Brown sugar, vanilla, and a hint of oak
  • Palate: Sweet toffee, cinnamon, light spice
  • Finish: Long, warm, and slightly dry

This flavor profile makes it an excellent entry-level bourbon while also earning respect from seasoned whiskey drinkers.

Perfect Pairings and Cocktails

Buffalo Trace bourbon is versatile. It shines in classic cocktails like:

  • Old Fashioned
  • Manhattan
  • Mint Julep
  • Whiskey Sour

For food pairings, try:

  • Grilled steak
  • Dark chocolate
  • Smoked brisket
  • Sharp cheeses

Where to Buy Buffalo Trace

Buffalo Trace is widely distributed across the U.S., but availability can vary depending on the state. It’s sold at:

  • Major liquor retailers (Total Wine, ABC, BevMo)
  • Online whiskey shops
  • Local craft spirits stores

Pro Tip: Some releases like Stagg Jr., Blanton’s, and Weller are allocated, meaning they’re released in small batches and can be hard to find. Join a local store’s bourbon list or whiskey club to improve your chances.

Collectibility & Limited Editions

Buffalo Trace’s Antique Collection and Weller series have become legends in the bourbon community. These include:

  • George T. Stagg
  • Thomas H. Handy Rye
  • William Larue Weller
  • Sazerac 18-Year Rye

Because of their rarity and quality, these bottles often appreciate in value and are sought after by collectors and enthusiasts worldwide.

Visiting Buffalo Trace Distillery

If you’re planning a Kentucky Bourbon Trail trip, a stop at Buffalo Trace is a must. The distillery offers:

  • Free guided tours
  • Tasting experiences
  • A gift shop with exclusive releases
  • A deep dive into bourbon history

Located just outside of Lexington, the Buffalo Trace Distillery experience combines American history, craftsmanship, and hospitality.

Final Thoughts: Why Buffalo Trace Deserves a Spot on Your Shelf

Whether you’re a seasoned bourbon collector or just starting your whiskey journey, Buffalo Trace is an essential brand. With accessible pricing, consistent quality, and a wide range of expressions, it’s the perfect gateway into the world of high-quality American bourbon.

For those chasing the rare, the distillery’s limited releases like Blanton’s, Stagg Jr., and Pappy Van Winkle offer excitement, exclusivity, and deep flavor that continues to earn Buffalo Trace its legendary reputation.

Shopping Cart